Who Needs A CMO Anyway?
Marc E. Babej and Tim Pollak 05.10.06, 6:00 AM ET
New York -
It's one of the hot jobs of the new millennium. Every corporation with a burgeoning C-suite wants to have one, and every self-respecting marketing executive aspires to be one.
But all the enthusiasm for the exalted title of chief marketing officer doesn't necessarily bespeak certainty about the role or relevance of the position.
The CMO title burst upon the scene during the dot-com boom. And like so many things during that period, it was driven by a preoccupation with appearances more than by practical need. Anointing a CMO was a cheap and easy way to create a perception of being marketplace-oriented and customer-centric.
Since then, the title has caught on. But underlying questions about the roles and responsibilities of CMOs haven't been resolved. The average CMO's tenure is only half that of a CEO, according to a Spencer Stuart survey. If so many CMOs don't live up to expectations, it's a sign that expectations aren't clear enough to begin with. The CMO function needs a better job description. Here's our take:
Broadly speaking, a CMO should be the interface between the company and the customer--responsible not only for marketing communications but also (sorry to be stepping on toes) for product development and sales. That makes it a very big job. But if it really deserves to be in the C-suite, it should be a big job,
More specifically, CMO responsibilities should include:
-- Ensuring the company's products and services are in tune with consumer demand. That's why a CMO, more than anyone else at the other C-levels, needs to be familiar with the wants and needs of customers and prospects. In fact, a CMO should be the representative of the customer within the C-suite.
-- Directing new product development and ensuring the continuing appeal of existing offerings. Marketers might lack detailed technical know-how, but, by virtue of their roles as marketplace experts, they are in a position to set research and development's agendas and approve output. This means no more resources wasted on products that customers don't have a reason to choose over the competition.
-- Marketing communications. To those who equate marketing with advertising, this is often seen as the primary CMO function. Marketing communications certainly are part of the CMO agenda, but they shouldn't define it. This is due to the simple reason that a great product will trump a bad ad, but a great ad won't save a bad product.
-- Hold CMOs accountable for achieving top-line growth objectives. Revenue and share offer the best measurement of how well a company fulfills the needs of its customers.
-- Hold CMOs accountable for meeting corporate margin goals. This will ensure that product formulation, pricing, trade and consumer promotion are balanced business decisions.
The long and short of it: If a company chooses to anoint a CMO, then the position must be invested with responsibilities, authority and accountability that befits a C-level title. Otherwise, why have a CMO at all?
Keep in mind that, for decades, managers with the "lowly" title of marketing senior vice president or executive vice president masterminded and spearheaded legendary marketing campaigns. The CMO function will only ever come into its own if it reflects a new understanding of the role of marketing within the company, as the discipline focused on creating and managing profitable growth in the marketplace.
Marc E. Babej and Tim Pollak are partners at Reason Inc., a marketing-strategy consulting firm that works with clients in a range of categories including media and entertainment, financial and professional services, packaged goods and the public sector.
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Wednesday, September 17, 2008
Have you tried the Tim Tam Slam?
Sunday, September 14, 2008
MIF Networking Session
This is long overdue. I'll just type all my 105b review of sessions so that when I have to write the report down one day, i'll just copy and paste from here>:D Sneaky, sneaky.
Met the guys at AMK station (Ju Hu, Ah Chen, MH) and they were ALL not wearing formal. Apparently I heard JC wrongly the other day:P So Ju Hu was there for the free food only.. But he's so funny, he thought we Muslims had different break fast times since the timing on our watches are different. So I enlightened him about something called a radio broadcast:)
The MIF networking session was a great experience. Silly me, brought a camera but DIDN'T USE IT. TSK. After eating the food, we sat down and waited for Evelyn Han to introduce the MIF session as a place for people who'd applied for the Mayor's fund to network with one another. Apparently, the networking session was a compulsory thing for those applicants. We started off with an ice breaker, Human interest bingo.
Then the two guest speakers (I think they were brilliant) started the ball rolling. The first was Immanuel Beauty School's Hazel Menon, who spoke of the struggles she faced as a social entrepreneur, basically changing the scheme of her beauty course to make her trainees pay a portion of their fees because they were simply not COMMITTING. They were having a problem with ownership of the course, because not only do these trainees (most are female ex-prison offenders) getting an allowance during their training course, their employers were also guaranteed. This speaker was colourful - she had so many stories of her trainees that during the networking bit, when we approached her, she ended up regaling the stories for a full 1 hour O_O
But I find her to be very approachable, very willing to help and dispense advise. Asking her about Sparkle and what are the procedures to provide certification for the trainees, she gave us the full picture, and more. One has to commit to a trainer course given by ACTA (sp?) for 1.5 months, plan the trainee programme to meet the requirements of the WDA, then apply for approval. Quite a long process I might say that requires a lot of commitment that students like us just can't give. I guess Sparkle will have to wait. Plus she gave some insider info as to how she managed to attract employers to sign up for her programme ;) You must have some bargaining power lah, and good networks too.
Followed up with our session by sending her an email.
The second speaker was colourful. Alvin Lee from Castle Beach. FIRST time I heard of someone actually OWNING a portion of any beach in Singapore. Well, he doesn't actually own them per se, he rents it from NP Parks or something. This one had plenty of entertaining jokes. But I think it's brilliant of him to come up with such a great outdoors bonding/life skills learning activity. And the sandcastles you can create are TOO beautiful, it's crazy - I have to make them to believe it. See http://www.castlebeach.org/. His one take-away of the day: Do something that you are passionate about and any obstacles along the way will be peanuts to you.
And I love the creative aspect of building your own pushcart, plus the marketing involved. Kekeke. Proposal-making was fun lah, I feel like that's what I love doing, it didn't feel like a chore at all. Should think about marketing as one of my career choices;)
Some pictures from the proposal:




Project PoOOosh pushing BizBuzz pushcarts into the 22nd century!!
Met the guys at AMK station (Ju Hu, Ah Chen, MH) and they were ALL not wearing formal. Apparently I heard JC wrongly the other day:P So Ju Hu was there for the free food only.. But he's so funny, he thought we Muslims had different break fast times since the timing on our watches are different. So I enlightened him about something called a radio broadcast:)
The MIF networking session was a great experience. Silly me, brought a camera but DIDN'T USE IT. TSK. After eating the food, we sat down and waited for Evelyn Han to introduce the MIF session as a place for people who'd applied for the Mayor's fund to network with one another. Apparently, the networking session was a compulsory thing for those applicants. We started off with an ice breaker, Human interest bingo.
Then the two guest speakers (I think they were brilliant) started the ball rolling. The first was Immanuel Beauty School's Hazel Menon, who spoke of the struggles she faced as a social entrepreneur, basically changing the scheme of her beauty course to make her trainees pay a portion of their fees because they were simply not COMMITTING. They were having a problem with ownership of the course, because not only do these trainees (most are female ex-prison offenders) getting an allowance during their training course, their employers were also guaranteed. This speaker was colourful - she had so many stories of her trainees that during the networking bit, when we approached her, she ended up regaling the stories for a full 1 hour O_O
But I find her to be very approachable, very willing to help and dispense advise. Asking her about Sparkle and what are the procedures to provide certification for the trainees, she gave us the full picture, and more. One has to commit to a trainer course given by ACTA (sp?) for 1.5 months, plan the trainee programme to meet the requirements of the WDA, then apply for approval. Quite a long process I might say that requires a lot of commitment that students like us just can't give. I guess Sparkle will have to wait. Plus she gave some insider info as to how she managed to attract employers to sign up for her programme ;) You must have some bargaining power lah, and good networks too.
Followed up with our session by sending her an email.
The second speaker was colourful. Alvin Lee from Castle Beach. FIRST time I heard of someone actually OWNING a portion of any beach in Singapore. Well, he doesn't actually own them per se, he rents it from NP Parks or something. This one had plenty of entertaining jokes. But I think it's brilliant of him to come up with such a great outdoors bonding/life skills learning activity. And the sandcastles you can create are TOO beautiful, it's crazy - I have to make them to believe it. See http://www.castlebeach.org/. His one take-away of the day: Do something that you are passionate about and any obstacles along the way will be peanuts to you.
And I love the creative aspect of building your own pushcart, plus the marketing involved. Kekeke. Proposal-making was fun lah, I feel like that's what I love doing, it didn't feel like a chore at all. Should think about marketing as one of my career choices;)
Some pictures from the proposal:




Project PoOOosh pushing BizBuzz pushcarts into the 22nd century!!
SIM 1 NTU STORM 6
Extremely proud of NTU Storm, we have outdone ourselves. I watched (during the first two periods where I wasn't playing) the best game that I have ever seen NTU Storm playing. Fighting a 50-50 game against SIM, and where just in the previous match against the Ewoks where we played disappointingly, we have somehow managed to bounce back, and like Jackie/Pinky said, things just 'clicked' and we remained focused and had a never-say-die attitude throughout the game:) Jamie even let everyone play.
We let SIM get the first goal in (that was a confusion goal-> a change in line during a WALL formation *faints*), but after that, though there were quite a few scares, we started hitting goals in one by one. Some casualties during the game, e.g. Yiping getting hit in the eye, a SIM girl crashing down into the boards, etc. But I felt like both teams truly wanted the ball, and SIM gave us a good fight, right till the end. They put in 6 players, sans goalie a few minutes into the end of the game.
And I don't know what came over me. I think my mind is detached from my body when I'm playing floorball. Somehow, during the change in line, when it was my turn to go in, I just CHARGED without thinking at a stray ball that had somehow been carelessly passed to the SIM defender and shot a goal in. That was a good feeling: ) Final score: 6-1.
I guess we finally did Jamie proud!
We let SIM get the first goal in (that was a confusion goal-> a change in line during a WALL formation *faints*), but after that, though there were quite a few scares, we started hitting goals in one by one. Some casualties during the game, e.g. Yiping getting hit in the eye, a SIM girl crashing down into the boards, etc. But I felt like both teams truly wanted the ball, and SIM gave us a good fight, right till the end. They put in 6 players, sans goalie a few minutes into the end of the game.
And I don't know what came over me. I think my mind is detached from my body when I'm playing floorball. Somehow, during the change in line, when it was my turn to go in, I just CHARGED without thinking at a stray ball that had somehow been carelessly passed to the SIM defender and shot a goal in. That was a good feeling: ) Final score: 6-1.
I guess we finally did Jamie proud!
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
STRETCHED
This Ramadhan has been really challenging.
No food
No time
No energy
No clean bill of health
No stress-free zones
Heck, even play has been stressful (i.e. floorball)
Imagine a rubber band stretched to its limits and YET there are sharp items rubbing on it, willing it to BREAK.
I am tired.
I just wanna sleep and enjoy blissful dreams in La La Land.
The only consolation is Chinese classes, where I actually feel like I'm progressing. The rest of the seminars have been like - a step forwards and 3 steps backwards.
No food
No time
No energy
No clean bill of health
No stress-free zones
Heck, even play has been stressful (i.e. floorball)
Imagine a rubber band stretched to its limits and YET there are sharp items rubbing on it, willing it to BREAK.
I am tired.
I just wanna sleep and enjoy blissful dreams in La La Land.
The only consolation is Chinese classes, where I actually feel like I'm progressing. The rest of the seminars have been like - a step forwards and 3 steps backwards.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
